Diotima and aspasia are the only two women who are characterized as. Diotima is the name of new yorkbased experimental black metal band krallices third album. An ancient city of southern greece in the eastern peloponnesus. The symposium is the dialogue set during an all night banquet where the participants decide to examine the concept of love. Socrates and diotima statues university of western australia. In the spirit of freshness, i will focus on one very important section, where socrates relates the words of his teacher diotima on the. The battle was to determine which of the two alliances would have hegemony over greece. Volume 1, ancient women philosophers published in 1987 covers 600 bc500 ad, and the early and late pythagoreans, aspasia of miletus, diotima of mantinea waithe makes a strong argument for her historicity, contrary to the usual perception of diotima as a fictitious character in platos dialogue symposium, julia domna, makrina, and.
The symposium puts diotima of mantinea amongst the top three women. Diotimas ladder in platos symposium, socrates recalls a speech told by priestess diotima from mantinea. According to diotima, love is not a god at all, but is rather a spirit that mediates between people and the objects of their desire. In my book i present the evidence to show that diotima is in fact a thinlyveiled disguise for aspasia. It should be noted that no women are present at the banquet. In the peloponnesian war a coalition led by mantinea and argos and urged on by athens was defeated 418 b. Part of the a history of women philosophers book series howp, volume 1 abstract diotima and aspasia are the only two women who are characterized as philosophers in the socratic dialogues of plato although other women, notably axiothea of philesia and lasthenia of mantinea, are known to have been students of plato. Most of the arguments put forth are based on analyzing the symposium. We must turn our attention to diotima, her characteristics, and her function as a knower in the dialog.
The first idea put forth to solve the puzzle of diotimas existence is that the form of beauty is inconsistent with platos form of the good. In 419 bc, the argives attacked the epidaurians, a minor state allied to sparta, the traditional enemy of argos. His historical arguments are based on 1 the likelihood of aspasias involvement in the. Symposium, platos philosophical text dated at circa 385 to 370 bc, depicts a friendly contest of speeches delivered by a group of notable men attending a banquet. Even so, we have the word of two reliable philosophers, who stated without reservation, that diotima of mantinea gave the world the best of all possible loves. Diotima, who influenced socrates, supposedly was a priestess there. Martini fisher comes from a family of history and culture buffs.
Specifically, i take the point to be that the study of women in the history of philosophy is philosophy insofar as it leads us to new thoughts, ideas, and ways of conceiving the world that we would not have noticed otherwise, with the result that encouraging the study of women in the history of philosophy allows philosophy to flourish more. The great battle of mantinea also called second mantinea to distinguish it from the events of 418 was a technical victory for thebes in the strictly military sense, but as xenophon noted it was actually indecisive. The following is my own interpretation based on the limited exposure we have to diotima provided by socrates and nothing more. Martini fisher is a mythographer and author of many books, including time. Egalitarianism, in their view, harbors the danger of sterility and of similarity of thought. Symposium by plato diotima questions socrates and the. If you are the publisher or author of this book and feel. Diotima a woman from mantinea whom socrates claims once to have met, and who taught him everything he knows on the subject of love. There is very good reason to doubt if diotima is meant to represent any real person, especially since her speech is so authoritative and oracular. Mantinea definition of mantinea by the free dictionary. In this speech, diotima counters socratess belief that love is beautiful and good, scolds him, and tells him that just because something is not beautiful does not.
Diotima practices an organizational structure that functions on both horizontal and vertical lines. In the symposium, diotima was a priestess from mantinea who postponed a. Aspasia, socrates and the roots of western philosophy. Until the early 5th century bc, it had been a cluster of five villages, but, at the suggestion of argos, the villages were. Diotima was an ancient greek prophetess and philosopher thought to have lived circa 440 b. Anna cremaldi phl 3000 3 october 2016 ascending to love.
Mantinea definition and meaning collins english dictionary. However, the death of epaminondas and his intended. Diotima of mantinea all about heaven sources returnpage. The second battle of mantinea was fought on july 4, 362 bc between the thebans, led by epaminondas and supported by the arcadians and the boeotian league against the spartans, led by king agesilaus ii and supported by the eleans, athenians, and mantineans. The spartans gathered a powerful army and marched to argos, where king agis, the spartan cinc, negotiated a 4month truce with the argives.
Antigoneia was a city in ancient arcadia, greece that was the site of two significant battles in classical greek history. Diotima of mantinea is a major figure in platos symposium. Plato on true love platos account of true love is still the most subtle and beautiful there is. Platos symposium is one of the most loved classics from the ancient world, a work of consummate beauty as both philosophy and as literature, most appropriate since the topic of this dialogue is the nature of love and includes much philosophizing on beauty. Another argument given to separate diotima and plato is that the form of beauty is on the. The end of this speech is radically different than anything else. Diotima of mantinea is one of the two main characters in the pericles commission and the ionia sanction by gary corby. In the dialogue, her ideas are the origin of the concept of platonic love. This book is the first in a series that summarise the findings and give links to the site where the detailed evidence can be found. Epaminondass death permanently crushed theban hopes of leadership in greece. In the dialogue, her ideas are the origin of the concept of platonic love identity. In the symposium, diotima was a priestess from mantinea who postponed a plague and taught socrates the nature of love.
Plato, no doubt purposely, avoids putting his exposition of eros into the mouth of any historical person. Diotima di mantinea by maria zambrano, 9788877383358, available at book depository with free delivery worldwide. Socrates philosophy of love inspired by diotima princess. Diotima of mantinea, around 350380 bc historians know very little about diotima, but her words and ideas were preserved in platos symposium, his great treatise on the nature of love. Piecing together a few brief experiences and descriptions of this character, we find a tantalizing puzzle. During the discussion, socrates mentions that, in his youth, he was taught the philosophy of. The second interpretation, which is the prevailing one, considers that diotima is a literary device that represents the philosopher par excellence. If the evidence for this thesis is accepted, the history of philosophy will have taken a momentous turn. Part of the a history of women philosophers book series howp, volume 1. This is the starting point, when love, which by definition is a desire for something we dont have, is first aroused by the sight of individual beauty.
Socrates philosophy of love inspired by diotima princess, priestess. His other accomplishments include the publishing of a book plaster casting for the student sculptor and the design of the oval ford insignia that is still in use today. While stressing sisterhood, diotima nonetheless recognizes preeminent figures of authority in the group. Artemision, mentioned as a source of soldiers in the catalog of ships in book ii of homers iliad. Diotima, the editor continues, seems an invention, whose purpose must be to distance the views socrates expresses in the dialogue about the. Foiled in a surprise attack on the unwalled city, epaminondas moved northwards to threaten the city of mantinea which had sided with the spartans. Diotima of mantinea is a female philosopher featured in platos symposium who, socrates says, taught him the philosophy of love. The siege of mantinea 385 bc saw the spartans take advantage of their dominant position in greece after the end of the corinthian war to attack one of their long standing local rivals and a halfhearted ally in the recent war mantinea was located about fifty miles from sparta. Mantinea article about mantinea by the free dictionary. Near the city was the dam of mantineia, one of the most advanced examples of ancient technology. Love is neither wise nor beautiful, but is rather the desire for wisdom and beauty. Mantinea synonyms, mantinea pronunciation, mantinea translation, english dictionary definition of mantinea.
Socrates in conversation with diotima by franz caucig 17551828. Diotima maps out the stages in this ascent in terms of what sort of beautiful thing the lover desires and is drawn toward. According aesara of lucania alexandria ancient apollonius archytas argument asclepigenia aspasia athens attributed augustan history beauty body book caracalla century b. Roughly half the characters in my books were real people. Diotima teaches socrates and giannina the meaning of love in giannina braschis postcolonial dramatic novel united states of banana.
Diotima s speech is the most serious speech of the night, completely changing the atmosphere of the room by its end. His teacher, socrates, chose not to write anything down in books or. Diotima mantinea is a fanfiction author that has written 4 stories for sailor moon. Featured in from fear of older to the wisdom of elder at sophias children. It was also the scene of the victory of thebes over sparta in which epaminondas epaminondas, d. However, diotima engages with the previous speeches, and their parts. Mantineia, ancient greek city of arcadia, situated about eight miles north of modern tripolis between mt. Dictionary grammar blog school scrabble thesaurus translator quiz more resources more from collins. Diotima of mantinea was an ancient greek prophetess and philosopher thought to have lived. Mantineia article about mantineia by the free dictionary. As nietzsche put it in his book of 1882, the gay science.
During the discussion, socrates mentions that, in his youth, he was taught the philosophy of love by a woman named diotima, a priestess from mantinea. The city was the place of the first battle of mantineia, in 418 bc, the largest land battle of the peloponnesian war. The real diotima only appears in one place in recorded history, but if you can only make. According to her, people can express love through reproduction both literally and metaphorically through reproducing to have children, or by sharing their. It has some light touches, but rises to a remarkable crescendo in tone in lines 208c209e.
732 823 837 1328 1048 600 1261 524 130 1330 318 566 409 1073 980 461 547 613 856 1354 1531 1561 47 1261 603 458 1330 1279 308 400 1247 1396 738